Issues Navigator

Global Challenges

Strategic Regions

Domestic Debates

Tag cloud

See All Tags

June 11, 2008 |  5 comments |  Print | E-Mail Your Opinion  

Frank-Walter Steinmeier & David Miliband

Addressing the Emerging Challenges of Climate Change

Frank-Walter Steinmeier & David Miliband: Germany and the UK want to develop an effective European and multilateral strategy to anticipate the new policy challenges of climate security. Indeed, an off-balance global climate will spawn ravaging crises, conflicts, and disasters that require an international response.

From the melting Arctic glaciers to the growing African deserts, climate change is a reality. It threatens our prosperity and well-being, not just in Europe but beyond. Moreover, it will reshape the geopolitics of the world in which we live, with significant consequences for peace and security.

Climate change will act as a stress multiplier. It will exacerbate existing pressure on scarce resources, particularly energy, water and food - we are already seeing record spikes in global food prices and growing concern over the consequences in places like China. Competition for scarce resources threatens to fuel migration.

The impact is likely to be most acute in regions such as the Sahel, the Middle East and South and Central Asia, which are prone to instability and where people are already socially and economically vulnerable. Rising sea levels and melting ice caps also risk triggering new conflicts over shifting maritime borders.

This is not an apocalyptic scenario. It is the assessment of increasing numbers of security experts based on the findings of climate scientists. Their conclusions demand a clear and coherent foreign and security policy response.

The European Union is already leading the global effort to tackle change. In Europe, we are building the world's first competitive, energy-secure low-carbon economy. Alongside developing the world's first functioning carbon market, we committed ourselves last year to meeting ambitious targets designed to put us on a fast track to de-carbonizing the European economy - 20 percent of total energy to come from renewable sources by 2020, 12 demonstration Carbon Capture and Storage plants by 2015 and a 20 percent reduction in total greenhouse gas emissions by 2020, 30 percent if other developed countries show similar ambition.

Internationally, we are pushing mitigation efforts under the Kyoto Protocol and working hard to broker a post-2012 global climate deal. We launched negotiations at the UN meeting in Bali in December. It is now imperative that we agree on an ambitious, binding, comprehensive and equitable agreement by the end of 2009 at the UN meeting in Copenhagen.

And we have put the security implications of climate change on top of theinternational agenda. In 2007, the UK initiated a debate in the UN Security Council on the impacts of climate change on peace and security. During its EU presidency in 2007, Germany initiated a report on a European response to the new security risks. European leaders discussed the report and endorsed its findings and recommendations at their Spring Council in March 2008.

Both the UK and Germany support a European response to the emerging security challenges of climate change. We want to help implement an effective European and multilateral strategy to address the new threats.

What are the important elements of such a strategy?

  1. We should intensify our efforts to meet the new security risks triggered by climate change. With the European Union's strategy for Central Asia and the new EU-Africa partnership, we have groundbreaking policy frameworks that will allow us to mainstream climate security into the EU's regional policies. In Central Asia, trans-boundary water management is an important pillar within our strategy. By helping build capacity, fostering regional dialog, and setting up more efficient water infrastructure, we are promoting water as a focus of regional co-operation, rather than regional division. The same is true for Africa, where the effects of food insecurity, water shortages and extreme weather are likely to be severe. The EU-Africa Partnership gives priority to more cooperation to address land degradation and increased aridity. Promoting food security through initiatives like the "Green Wall for the Sahara" is a key element for political stability and crisis prevention in Africa.

  2. We will have to address an increasing number of global natural disasters such as storms, floods and droughts in the future. There is a strong case for closer monitoring of climate-related developments in crisis-prone areas. But we also need to prepare for increased demand for European-led disaster management and humanitarian relief.

  3. We need to consider now how climate change will affect the strategy context of European foreign and security policy in the years to come. For instance, the shrinking Arctic icecap could raise questions about resources, delimitation of maritime zones and sea lanes in the far north. To avoid new tensions, the EU report on climate security proposes a European Arctic policy. It is vitally important for European security to implement governance structures for the Arctic region based on international law, aiming at a cooperative and peaceful management of resources and preserving the ecological heritage of mankind.

Anticipating new foreign policy challenges and reinforcing the climate security and conflict prevention aspects of our regional strategies are important steps in defining a joint EU response. These efforts will help us to avoid growing resentment between those most responsible for climate change and those most affected by it. A potential stand-off between "polluters" - both in the North and among the emerging economies - and "victims," who will be predominantly in the South, would put the already burdened international security architecture under increasing pressure.

Ultimately, there is no hard power option for tackling the causes of the climate threat or for dealing with its direct impacts. You cannot use military force to build a low carbon global economy; no weapons system can halt the advance of a hurricane bearing down on a city or hold back the rising sea. But what the emerging analysis on climate and security tells us is that we can be sure that there will be hard power consequences if we fail to rise to the challenge.

Frank-Walter Steinmeier is the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Germany and David Miliband is the British Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs. This text was first published here in The German Times.

Related materials from the Atlantic community:

  • 17
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this Article! What's this?

 
 
Comments
Jens F. Laurson

June 12, 2008

  • 3
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Simply repeating the tired and publicity-efficient half-truths and stereotypes about global warming won't make them so.

This is not part of the thoughtful debate on global warming, its effects (positive and negative alike), and its causes (to which humans arguably contribute a minimal amount). It's part of a Zeitgeist-wave riding green populism that wishes to do good, and will likely cause more harm instead.

It's reverse Goethe (Faust I): ein Teil von jener Kraft, die stets das Gute will und stets das Boese schafft. (A part of that force, which always intends good, and yet always achieves evil)."
 
James  Cricks

June 12, 2008

  • 3
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
It is heartening to see British Foreign Minister Miliband and German Foreign Minister Steinmeier discussing the impacts of climate change. Europe has certainly taken a lead in stimulating discussion and creating policies for mitigation. They are rightfully considering how Africa and other fragile areas are being forever changed.

In an earlier time, European multilateral consensus may have been sufficient to settle important issues but I would submit one of the first steps should be to recognize the critical roles of China, India, and other emerging economies in creating solutions. I understand why they might want to ignore the US but Europe must also be ready to respond when the next administration begins to make overtures in 2009. If their intent is only to have a good conscience, they should be pleased with their work but if they intend to adequately prepare they will need to cast a broader net.

There will be hard power consequences no matter what Europe does so they should begin the transformation of their military forces to deal with it. They rightly mentioned the scramble in the Arctic region that is already occurring. A post-Cold War lesson should be that it takes Europe a long time to transform so they should start to consider some hard choices now.

Europe should not bet its civilization on rosy scenarios. Populations will be moving as water becomes more scarce creating Darfur-like situations of greater magnitude. These migration flows will be looking at Europe as their best option and hoping that Europe will be able to respond in a generous manner.

More frank assessments will be important if the stress of this global challenge is not to overwhelm Europe. Germany and the UK can be catalysts but they are not central to the problem.
 
george  pieler

June 12, 2008

  • 3
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Messrs. Steinmeier and Milliband are masters of the rhetoric of global development, and many of their proposals (enhancing resource infrastructure in Africa, being better prepared to manage natural disasters) are simply unarguable. On the other hand, they don't mention why these things have not been accomplished, in over 60 years of massive development support from the developed nations and multilateral agencies like the World Bank. Aside, they recommend deployment of soft power alone, but the threats they discuss--resource wars, energy competition--quickly translate into hard (military) power situations. C.F. Darfur, Abkhazia. The current tragedy in Burma should tell us more than soft power is needed. Finally, whether one believes the European climate change narrative in all its details (carbon-driven warming which can be regulated somehow) it seems odd to ignore vital measures such as using carbon-based fuels more efficiently, and deploying nuclear power, in their outline of important measures. Particularly when so much of central Europe is in some degree of carbon servitude to Russia.
 
Donald  Stadler

June 12, 2008

  • 1
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
"They are rightfully considering how Africa and other fragile areas are being forever changed."

Yes, particularly the fringes of the Sahara Desert. When was the last time anyone has heard of the once ubiquitous Sahara-fringe famine? Been a while hasn't it?

I've read that parts of the Sahara have been 'greening', surely a very bad thing to do to such a fragile ecosystem. Except perhaps for one thing: Archeologists tell us that much of the Sahara basin used to be a fine green area suitable for grazing livestock, and it was the actions of early farmers which cause the desert to appear or at least to expand.

So it's a very bad thing that the Sahara is receding and people are being fed, no?

 
ilyas m mohsin

June 13, 2008

  • 1
  •  
  •  
  • No rating possible
  • No rating possible
I like this comment! What's this?
Climate change is here and one does not have to be metrologist to feel the same. However, despite Kyoto protocol and Bali delibrations, the equation between the "polluters" and the "victims" remains apocalyptic.
The major polluters headed by the US appear to be resorting to diversionary tactics to maintain the status quo.
Arctic scenario should serve as an eye-opener to us all. So we, who inhabit the Globe, should seriously cut our foul Gas Emissions to the minimum levels as afr as possible across the board.
If Sahara gets rehabilitated due the climate cahnge, it would be a welcome dvelopment for humanity as Green is the anti-thesis of Desert.
 

Create Comment

Type the characters shown in the image below into the textfield.
Captcha

What are tags?

Community

Jobs / Internships

Call for Papers

Atlantic Events

Partners

User of the day

Maria Marta Ferretti
Maria Marta Ferretti
Member since
June 4, 2007

Poll


DW-WORLD.DE


Europe
Europe
Business




DW-TV Live DW-Radio Live